Ask the right questions about paint performance

by anthony_capkun_2 | November 18, 2026 11:15 am

[1]
The session “Demystifying the paint specification process” with speaker Scott Frankert of PPG at Metalcon 2026 in Orlando.

Just because a paint specification calls for a particular test doesn’t necessarily mean that test is appropriate for the product or its intended application.

That was among the messages delivered by Scott Frankert during his session “Demystifying the paint specification process” at Metalcon 2026[2]. He challenged attendees to think critically about the testing methods they specify, what those tests actually measure, and how well the results predict a coating’s performance in the real world.

Start with the material specification

A material spec is a technical document defining the desired properties of a material or system, including its substrate, treatments, paint finish, packaging, and approved suppliers.

Within that broader document is the paint spec, which outlines the requirements for a paint system, including the testing standards or methods to be used and the performance criteria the coating must satisfy (e.g. FGIA/AAMA 2605).

Paint performance can vary significantly depending on the substrate, Frankert said. A coating applied to steel may perform differently when applied to aluminum, which is why the paint spec must reflect the requirements of the material and its intended application.

It is for this reason that simply copying paint specs from one project to another can cause problems. The materials, fabrication processes, environmental exposures, and expected service lives may be entirely different.

And specifying the duration of a test doesn’t necessarily tell you what you need to know. For example, one test may require 1,000 hours of salt spray on the painted surface, but then what constitutes acceptable performance after those 1,000 hours?

The acceptance criteria must be defined, Frankert argued, not just the test method and duration.

The requirements for a metal roof expected to last 50 years in a coastal environment, for example, are very different from those for a refrigerator panel designed for 10 years of service indoors.

What are we trying to predict?

According to Frankert, the paint spec and testing must account for two distinct sets of conditions.

The first involves fabrication and processing. Coatings may be subjected to rollforming, bending, stamping, laser cutting, perforating, embossing, slitting, and other manufacturing operations.

Transportation, installation, adhesives, protective films, and other processing considerations can also affect the finished product.

The second involves the service environment, where the coating must withstand the daily conditions it encounters over its life. These may include:

The challenges of testing

Frankert identified three key challenges when developing paint specifications:

1. Correlation between laboratory and field performance. Lab testing can provide valuable information, but the results do not always accurately predict what will happen in service. Established coating technologies with long field histories can be easier to evaluate.

2. Validity of test methods. Tests must deliver appropriate levels of precision, accuracy, and repeatability to produce meaningful results.

3. Overengineering. Unrealistic performance expectations or poorly selected criteria can result in inappropriate specs and misleading assessments of coating performance.

Standard versus self-developed test methods

Frankert also compared standardized test methods with those developed for particular applications.

Standard methods, commonly established by standards organizations and trade associations, benefit from broad industry acceptance and repeatability. However, they may be too general to reflect the conditions encountered in a particular fabrication process or service environment.

Self-developed methods, often created by manufacturers, OEMs, or other organizations, can be tailored to specific requirements. Their limitations may include inconsistent results between laboratories and narrower industry acceptance.

Neither approach is universally superior. In fact, some paint specs incorporate both.

Are established testing methods always appropriate?

Frankert then turned to several commonly used test methods, highlighting their strengths and limitations.

ASTM B117 (salt spray testing) is widely used to assess corrosion resistance, but Frankert questioned its correlation with actual environmental exposure. The continuous salt spray provides no recovery period for the test specimen, potentially producing false negative results.

ASTM D3363 (pencil hardness testing) leads to shortcomings in precision and repeatability. What kind of pencil is being used in the test and by whom? He suggested that ISO 1518-1 may offer a more suitable alternative in certain applications.

ASTM G152 (carbon arc light exposure) is used to evaluate the effects of light exposure on materials. It continues to appear in specs for some legacy products, despite being phased out in favor of newer approaches.

ASTM D4060 (taber abrasion testing) is used to evaluate wear through appearance changes and mass loss, but can produce false positive or negative results. Frankert encouraged the use of alternative methods.

ASTM D4145 (T-bend flexibility testing) is an inexpensive way to evaluate coating flexibility during deformation, but it may warrant additional or alternative testing.

Frankert’s goal was not to get designers to abandon these methods, but rather to get them to understand what each test measures, its limitations, and whether the results are meaningful for the intended application.

Think critically about performance

Ultimately, Frankert encouraged attendees to move beyond specs inherited from previous projects or carried forward simply because they have been used for years.

Instead, understand the substrate, fabrication process, anticipated service environment, and desired service life. Then select the testing methods and acceptance criteria that best reflect those conditions.

A familiar test isn’t necessarily the right test.


Anthony Capkun is the editor-in-chief of Metal Architecture[3] and Metal Construction News[4] magazines.

[5]

Endnotes:
  1. [Image]: https://www.metalarchitecture.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/Metalcon-2026-Session-Scott-Frankert.webp
  2. Metalcon 2026: https://metalcon.com/
  3. Metal Architecture: https://www.metalarchitecture.com/
  4. Metal Construction News: https://www.metalconstructionnews.com/
  5. [Image]: https://www.metalarchitecture.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/09/Editors-Corner-MCN-MA-Mug02-800.jpg

Source URL: https://www.metalarchitecture.com/articles/ask-the-right-questions-about-paint-performance/