Cooling Off: Large diameter, low speed fans boost HVAC systems

by Jonathan McGaha | May 31, 2010 12:00 am

By Paul Deffenbaugh

HVAC systems are receiving a boost from large diameter, low speed fan technology and it couldn’t have come at a better time. With increased energy and material costs and a wave of green activity encompassing everything from building design to construction to overall use, incorporating airmovement is becoming as common as T8 lights and low VOC coatings. New, innovative products and strategies are helping to create the ideal indoor atmosphere by taking into account employee needs along with employer budgets. According to the Center for the Built Environment, “Tech Notes: Productivity and IEQ Satisfaction,” temperature, air quality and noise level are the three most important factors when considering productivity. Lexington, Ky.-based Big Ass Fans has worked diligently over the past decade to address these three factors while maintaining its fundamentally sustainable approach.

Silent Comfort
HVAC systems are rather costly both in terms of upfront installation and material as well as ongoing maintenance and usage. A June 2009 ASHRAE Journal article entitled “Managing Energy and Comfort,” states that many facility managers measure energy use but few measure comfort. Part of the problem, reports the author, “is that energy costs are visible and easy to measure, while comfort is difficult to measure.” Equally troublesome, building material, age, design, geographic region and the activities taking place within a facility often render traditional HVAC systems insufficient. “In larger, open spaces or small spaces where the occupants maintain varying comfort levels, it’s hard to maintain comfort without proper airflow,” said Christian Taber, applications engineer for Big Ass Fans.”

Large diameter, low speed ceiling fans can ensure adequate air movement throughout a facility, providing an effective, energy-efficient solution to occupant comfort.” Large diameter, low speed fans help decrease reliance on noisy, high-cost HVAC systems by silently, effectively circulating air while still providing the much needed comfort. Big Ass Fans’ commercial-grade fans include the 12- to 20-foot(4- to 6-m) diameter Element and the 8- to 10-foot (2- to 3-m) diameter Isis which both produce less than 40 dBA at maximum operating speed, making them ideal for use in sound sensitive areas. The fan’s direct-drive motor eliminates the audible mechanical noise created by gearbox friction commonly found in large fans. Due to their advanced onboard controls, Element and Isis do not generate any electrical ‘noise’ including radio frequency interference that affects electromagnetic equipment(e.g. computers, monitors).

Any Time of Year
One of the major benefits of using commercial grade large diameter, low speed fans in practice is their ability to significantly reduce the upfront and ongoing operating costs of the facility’s HVAC system.

Combating summer heat coupled with the need to provide winter heat destratification within a heavy trafficked University of Nevada, Las Vegas dorm proved reason enough for HVAC specialist Jim Stinar to research airmovement as a means to maintain comfort. The existing 40-year-old airhandling system provided acceptable comfort at the floor level, but was unable to address the vertical temperature discrepancy within the 16-foot- (5-m- ) high900-square-foot (84-m2) space. UNLV installed an 8-foot (2-m) Isis fan to provide the air movement necessary to destratify the air and regulate temperatures year-round. Initially, Stinar looked into adding a 2-ton (1.8-metric ton) airhandling unit to the space, a costlier and more labor intensive option. “The Big Ass Fan was much easier to install than having to run additional piping, let alone costs,” Stinar said.

With cost being such an important consideration,large diameter fan technology is gaining speed. Extremely efficient and easily integrated intoa building automation system, Element and Isis can operate as part of the HVAC system, reducing theneed for expensive ductwork. Working in tandem, the fans circulate the conditioned air, reduce the need for ductwork, and lower the load on the HVAC system. However, these fans produce enough airmovement to operate in lieu of an HVAC system if desired, especially in spaces where conditioning iscost-prohibitive or impractical.

Energy Efficiency
Ideal for user comfort in the cooling mode, Big Ass Fans create a “feeling of coolness” by aiding in evaporative cooling process. In destratification mode (cooler winter months),the fans operate for extended periods to prevent extreme temperature differences, continually mixing the air in the space-alleviating the heating load on the HVAC system and preventing the warm air from resting at the ceiling level.

Working with the existing air handling system, Big Ass Fans provide air movement and regulate temperatures within UNLV’s two-story lobby area, improving comfort both to those working within or just passing through. “It moves a lot of air very slowly which helps break up little pockets of air,” Stinar said. “Plus, the variable speeds allow us to adjust the airmovement on any given day.”

Due to its efficiency, Big Ass Fans can significantly help exceed the minimum requirements of ASHRAE 90.1, “Energy Standards for Buildings Except Low-rise Residential Buildings.” Moreover, they play a vital role in providing a comfortable working environment per requirements of ASHRAE 55.

As ASHRAE 90.1 and 55 are part of the USGBC’s LEED rating system, the installation of Big Ass Fans can help a project earn LEED points through optimize energy performance, minimum IAQ performance, increased ventilation, thermal comfort and innovation in design.

The Ultimate Payback
When Big Ass Fans are used in new construction, materials (i.e. ductwork, diffusers, HVAC supply fan motor) and labor can be reduced, lowering first costs of the HVAC system and providing an instantaneous payback. In existing buildings, payback depends on several variables, including ceiling height, how often the thermostat is reset in the summer, electricity and gas costs, and rebate values from utility companies. Although a return on investment period of three to five years is not out of the ordinary, Big Ass Fans have paid back in as little as three months.

Nina Wolgelenter is a writer at Big Ass Fans, Lexington, Ky. Visit www.bigassfans.com for more information.

Source URL: https://www.metalarchitecture.com/articles/cooling-off-large-diameter-low-speed-fans-boost-hvac-systems/