by Jonathan McGaha | March 6, 2011 12:00 am
Since the introduction of the U.S. Green Building Council’s LEED rating system, many owners and project teams have struggled through the process of getting their buildings certified. One explanation for this is that they have not taken the time to learn and understand what it takes to achieve certification. This lack of knowledge is not restricted to the design team or the contractor; it is prevalent throughout the entire delivery team.
Owners
Owners often make the decision to go green without really knowing what they are asking of the team. Sometimes their decision is based on the allure of owning a LEED certified building. A desire to achieve certification could also be tied to a mandate or an incentive by a local municipality. Making the decision to pursue certification should not be made in haste. It should be based on knowing the facts and understanding what it will take to achieve certification. Making a decision based on something other than the facts can cause a failure to ask the right questions when assembling the rest of the delivery team. For instance, an owner may ask how much experience a project team has with LEED, but does not ask for their success rate in getting projects certified. It is easy to register a project with USGBC, but it is much harder to get a project certified. An owner who understands the process knows that there must be a commitment from every member of the team. Success in achieving LEED certification takes more than just adding words to a specification.
Designers
Designers play a big part in a project’s LEED certification. However, those without a keen understanding of the requirements of any given rating system may think that indicating a credit as achievable on a scorecard will be enough to succeed. Let’s consider LEED for New Construction and Major Renovations (LEED-NC) Indoor Environmental Quality Credit 5 (IEQc5): Indoor Chemical and Pollutant Source Control. This credit requires a number of elements and input from multiple design disciplines, including the following:
If a designer is unaware of the nuances of even one of these requirements, the project cannot achieve the credit. The design team also needs to understand how this credit may affect other prerequisites and credits. The design may include all of the required elements to comply with IEQc5, but the use of large filters on both the return and supply side can increase the amount of energy needed to run the system. Achieving this credit, and the single LEED point associated with it, may decrease the amount of points awarded for Energy and Atmosphere Credit 1: Optimize Energy Efficiency, which is worth 19 points. In an extreme case, the project’s ability to achieve Energy and Atmosphere Prerequisite 2: Minimum Energy Performance may be affected as well, which would jeopardize the project’s entire LEED certification. Many LEED prerequisites and credits are interrelated and often dependent on one another. A simple misunderstanding of a LEED requirement can have profound consequences for the project.
Contractors
A number of credits rely on the work of the contractor. It is unfortunate that some design specifications call for achievement of certain credits and leave it up to the contractor to figure out what it takes to succeed. This situation is often encountered with IEQc3.2: Construction Indoor Air Quality Management Plan-Before Occupancy. This credit calls for the contractor to either flush the building with outside air or test the air quality inside of the building before the owner takes occupancy. The rating system defines this as a Construction Phase credit, which means the contractor holds primary responsibility for the documentation necessary to confirm compliance. However, if contractors do not fully understand the requirements of this credit, they cannot properly plan or price the effort it will take to achieve this credit. A contractor must run the mechanical system after all construction activities are complete until 14,000 cubic feet of outdoor air has been delivered for every square foot of the building. If the schedule does not allow for a building flush, an air quality test can be performed to prove compliance. The building flush-out option sounds like an easy way to achieve this credit, but how much time should a contractor put into the schedule? The time it takes to perform flush-out is dependent on how much outdoor air the mechanical system is designed to provide. A system that is capable of delivering 100 percent outdoor air will take less time than a system that is restricted to 10 percent outdoor air. Either way, someone must perform the calculations to determine how long a building flush will take. Knowing this is only one piece of the compliance puzzle. The delivery of the outdoor air must also be in a controlled environment with an acceptable temperature and humidity range. Once again, fully understanding the intricacies of the requirements is crucial to the project’s success.
Education Leads to Success
It is critical that project teams understand the LEED requirements and the tremendous impact that their decisions can have on other elements of their buildings. Achieving LEED certification takes a strong commitment from the owner, a deep understanding of the synergistic relationships between the prerequisites and credits by the design team, and detailed knowledge of the rating system requirements by the contractor. Self-education, building on the collective knowledge of the entire delivery team, is the best way to predict LEED success.
Thomas Taylor, a 29-year veteran of the construction industry and noted expert on sustainability, is the general manager of St. Louis-based Vertegy, a sustainability consultancy firm that was launched in February 2005 following the success of the LEED Platinum Alberici Corporate Headquarters. His recent book, “Guide to LEED 2009: Estimating and Preconstruction Strategies,” provides step-by-step information about the LEED 2009 for New Construction process. Vertegy provides clients with design, procurement and construction consulting services for green and sustainable facilities. To learn more about Vertegy or Taylor’s new book, visit www.vertegyconsultants.com for more information.
Source URL: https://www.metalarchitecture.com/articles/education-is-the-key/
Copyright ©2026 Metal Architecture unless otherwise noted.