Window of Opportunity: Energy modeling optimizes product selection

by Jonathan McGaha | September 30, 2012 12:00 am

wausau2Building envelope upgrades, including window replacement, offer significant energy savings and other benefits. In many aging buildings, existing windows are leaky, single-glazed sash with conductive framing systems. They can be difficult-or even dangerous-to operate, promote mold or mildew formation, and force occupants to keep their distance from exterior walls due to glare, drafts and noise. A successful window replacement involves meeting performance requirements for thermal transmittance, condensation resistance, acoustics, ventilation, view and solar heat gain, as well as aesthetic considerations.

 

Today’s facilities professionals consider both the economic and environmental factors involved, including carbon footprint reduction, maintenance savings, safety and occupant productivity. For replacement projects, perimeter zone energy consumption and peak energy demand is estimated for existing and new window systems, using one or more energy modeling tools.

 

The U.S. Department of Energy and Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory’s COMFEN can be adapted to compare energy costs related to existing windows with those to be expected with new windows, while providing valuable information on glare and HVAC capacity reductions. Some window and curtainwall manufacturers also offer energy modeling tools online. For example, Wausau Window and Wall Systems’ “Green Product Selection Tool” allows users to gather performance information on:

 

Using cost savings estimates generated by these comparisons, project-specific, financial parameters can be applied to analyze payback time or rate of return. Assuming that energy cost inflation exceeds the normal inflation rate by a certain percentage, savings will grow year after year.

 

Of course, every institution’s method of calculating return on investment is different. Renovation design teams often provide the savings and costs information to financial staff or energy service companies for economic analysis, so applicable subsidies and tax credits can be factored into the equation. Financial assumptions can have a more significant effect on payback time than fenestration design parameters, especially for tax-exempt institutions and properties.

 

wausau1Local energy codes often specifically address historical building renovation. In some cities and designated historic districts, the exterior appearance of proposed replacement windows also is considered a worthwhile asset and requires approval. Such approvals serve to maintain period ambience, which may help preserve both property values and the community’s sense of place. In some cases, changes of mere millimeters of a window frame’s sightline dimension have been deemed unacceptable, necessitating custom solutions.

 

Design teams often select replacement windows that feature a narrow, beveled exterior face replicating the look of classic, putty-glazed steel and wood windows, while offering modern, high performance. Snap-in grid muntins or low-profile true divided lite muntins, along with renovation panning at the perimeter of window openings, may be added to emphasize historic styling.

 

In many historically influenced replacement projects, the windows being replaced are tall, double- or triple-hung sash, used for natural daylighting in buildings that were constructed before the prevalence of artificial lighting. When upgraded from single glazing to double (or triple) insulating glass these tall, hung sash get quite heavy.

 

The combination of large sash size, heavier insulating glass and tight air seals may make replacement double-hung windows difficult to operate, even with modern balance technology. Lift assistance varies from 30 to 70 percent depending on balance type, but longevity of these heavy-use hardware components can be an issue, too soon requiring yet another replacement.

 

Projected windows offer an easy-to-operate alternative. As the name implies, projected windows function by swinging inward or outward from the plane of the wall. As these vent types are compression sealed, low air infiltration does not require high operating force, and smooth-operating cam locks, keepers, friction hinges or butt hinges are long-lived. Limited opening devices prevent excessive projection into adjacent areas. Projected windows can even offer the ‘offset’ glass plane appearance of hung sash.

 

Historic window replacement requires easy customization of window sash and durable finishes in a wide range of colors. These needs make aluminum a logical choice. Factory-applied anodize and baked-on fluropolymer finishes offer long-lasting options to match existing color schemes, or to return exterior and interior surfaces to their original colors, after years of chalking, peeling or repainting.

 

In cases where rigorous replication of existing window sightlines and colors is an absolute requirement, new, custom extrusion die profiles often are designed. This is where aluminum excels as a framing material choice: Tooling is relatively inexpensive, profiles can be extruded in almost any conceivable shape, and aluminum’s high strength-to-weight ratio keeps sightlines narrow.

 

In some cases, wire profile gages are used to ‘trace’ the existing framing design and new custom die profiles are designed accordingly. Projected windows can be customized with only a handful of new die profiles. Standard thermal barriers can be incorporated in custom shapes to ensure energy efficiency.

 

—

Steve Fronek, P.E., LEED Green Associate, is the vice president of technical services at Wausau Window and Wall Systems, Wausau, Wis. For more information, visit www.wausauwindows.com[1].

Endnotes:
  1. www.wausauwindows.com: http://www.wausauwindows.com

Source URL: https://www.metalarchitecture.com/articles/know-your-products-window-of-opportunity/