LEEDing the Way: Selecting the Right Team

by Jonathan McGaha | October 3, 2011 12:00 am

Usgbc Logo 01

Many owners looking to build a sustainable office to suit their needs have never been involved with a construction project before, and therefore, may not know where to get started. Their reasoning behind building a green space may be connected with their concern for the environment or could result from their clients making spending decisions based on their social and environmental views and choosing companies that share these same principles. Whatever the reasoning, it is safe to say that the key to any successful project is selecting the right team. So how do you find the right team?

Traditional Delivery Model

In a traditional delivery model, an owner starts the process by seeking the advice of an architect. The selection of this person or firm might be based on friendships, business relationships, word of mouth or a competitive bidding process. Once selected, the architect will recommend or select the various design team members needed for the project. This selection process varies among firms and is dependent on the type of the project, the size of project, the schedule and in-house capabilities. The amount of input the owner has in the selection of the team will depend greatly on how involved an owner wishes to be. This can range from no involvement at all to providing input on every decision made. Once the design team has been selected, they begin their work, which eventually culminates in a set of drawings and specifications that will be used to solicit priced proposals from contractors who will then be responsible for the construction phase of the project.

But, while the traditional delivery model may work for a variety of construction projects, those seeking to achieve some recognizable sustainability goal may find it beneficial to move away from the traditional delivery model and seek something more applicable to the unique circumstances of the project.

Developing the Criteria for Success

The first step in doing this is preparing a list of things that can be used to define the success of your project before starting the team selection process. Choose items that, either by themselves or in combination with each other, create the best building possible when the project is complete. Take the time at the earliest stage of the project to think of all of the space and amenities that may be needed or wanted. Discuss with employees what could be included in the building that would make them more productive and satisfied with their workspace. Talk with peers and local lending institutions to help determine what a realistic budget might be for the type of space that best suits your needs. Walk around the existing office space to identify what works well for your team and what could be changed to improve comfort and output. These may seem to be logical first steps, but all too often, owners do not start here.

When compiling this list, owners may find that they have limited experience with the development process, especially as it relates to sustainability. If this is the case, it’s best to seek some assistance. While seeking the advice of professionals is a good idea, selecting team members before defining what your “best” project is may not always be in your best interest, so be sure not to jump ahead to this step. One reason for this is that everyone has their own definition of what is “best” for them. Terms like “good,” “better,” “best” and “exceptional” mean different things to different people. If a professional is needed to help with the discovery stages of a project, hire a person or firm for just that-helping with discovery. This person may also be great with suggesting firms that are trustworthy and can deliver the project of your dreams for a budget you can afford.

Integrating the Criteria for Success

The rationale behind limiting early services to the discovery stage is so that the information gathered during that phase can be used for two distinct purposes. The first is to formulate the criteria that can be used at the completion of the project to determine if the team has delivered and achieved the goals that were established for the project. The other is to provide a framework that can be used to evaluate prospective team members before making a decision to offer them a position on your team. Providing them with a list of what you would like to have in your completed project and then asking them to explain how they will use their talents to deliver on those goals is a good evaluation technique. Any firm can show you a list of projects they have completed. Some may share beautiful pictures or renderings of projects they have worked on in the past. However, those pictures and an overwhelming list of past clients do not automatically mean that all of those projects successfully achieved the goals of the building owners. Rarely will a team member say to a prospective client, “Here’s a truly beautiful building that we worked on, and it was featured in a lot of magazines. Oh, by the way, it was 35 percent over budget.”

Another useful tool is to select individual team members instead of selecting a packaged team. Often team members have exceptional talents in one aspect of project delivery, but are lacking in other areas. An example might be an architect that is stellar in conceptual design but lacks in management ability. A firm may be able to perform both mechanical and electrical design in house, but its strength lies more in the electrical field than in mechanical. The point is that sometimes it is better to make the effort to assemble a team of individuals or firms who are extremely talented in one aspect of project delivery and limit their scope to those services instead of asking them to tack on additional scope in areas that are not their main strength. This is not always the easiest way to develop the team. Just because you assemble a group of people who are the best in their individual fields does not mean that they are always willing to work together, and someone needs to take responsibility to manage your team.

When utilizing an integrated approach to the design, construction and operation of the building, the effort put forth in selecting the right team members and making sure that each member is doing the tasks that align best with their talents will result in an investment that will be well worth the effort.

Thomas Taylor, a 29-year veteran of the construction industry and noted expert on sustainability, is
the general manager of St. Louis-based Vertegy. His recent book, “Guide to LEED 2009: Estimating
and Preconstruction Strategies,” provides step-by-step information about the LEED 2009 for New
Construction process. To learn more about Vertegy or Taylor’s new book, visit www.vertegyconsultants.com for more information

Source URL: https://www.metalarchitecture.com/articles/leeding-the-way-selecting-the-right-team/