Strategies to Achieve LEED Materials and Resources Credits

by Jonathan McGaha | April 3, 2011 12:00 am

Recently a student working on a class project to design a LEED certified building asked me what the easiest way is to achieve the Materials and Resources (MR) credit for recycled material. My response was, “It depends.” When one sets out to design a building in hopes of obtaining LEED certification, few things are absolute. There are definitely thresholds that must be met or definitive aspects that must be demonstrated in the design, but as far as how to go about achieving them, it is all up to the delivery team.

Achieving Goals

It is very restrictive and at times expensive to focus on any particular LEED credit. The easiest way to achieve the sustainability goals for a project seeking LEED certification is to take a more holistic approach. When looking to incorporate materials with high amounts of recycled content, a building owner or operator must first look at some of the overall design drivers for the project, such as:

All of these factors will influence the strategy for achieving the MR credits found in the LEED rating system.

Getting the Point

The majority of the Materials and Resources credits are based on some type of ratio or percentage threshold:

It is relatively simple for a project team to read the requirements of MRc3 through MRc6 and assume they will get that point. Making sure all the individual components of the design as a whole will work together to achieve each of those thresholds is another thing entirely.

So how can a team affirm that a project in the early stages of design will achieve a targeted MR credit? They can’t. However, a team can put together a strategy built on the concepts of sustainability that allows them to make a strong prediction that can morph into a validated estimate as the design matures.

Give and Take
Early design decisions will impact the material strategy for the project. For example, a building design utilizing a combination of cast-in-place concrete and precast or tilt-up exterior wall components can predict relatively easily that the structural components made from concrete will make up at least 20 percent of the total material cost of the project. In this case, compliance with MRc5: Regional Materials should be simple for the team to achieve because the base materials of the concrete are extracted, manufactured and processed within 500 miles of the job site.

However, a team with this same building design may struggle to find ways to incorporate materials
with enough recycled content to achieve the 20 percent threshold requirements of MRc4: Recycled

Content. Teams often believe that between using rebar and specifying a concrete mix with 15 percent fly ash, they can achieve the recycled content credit. However, as the following example illustrates, specifying fly ash and rebar will likely not be enough of a contribution to achieve MRc4: Recycled Content.

The recycled content of an assembled material is calculated based on the weight of the individual components of the assembly. Assume a project is using a cubic yard of concrete with the following component breakdown:

Component

Weight (lbs.)

Rock 25
Sand 25
Water 5
Cement 34
Fly Ash 6
Add Mix 5
Total Material Weight 100

The total recycled content of this yard of concrete is equal to the fly ash component (6 pounds). Fly ash is considered a pre-consumer recycled material, meaning it is recycled directly from industry before entering the consumer market stream. The calculations for MRc4: Recycled Content require that only 50 percent of the value of pre-consumer recycled materials contribute toward the total recycled content value. Therefore, the total recycled content from this yard of concrete is 3 pounds, which equals only 3 percent of the total weight of the concrete. For each
$100 of this concrete mix that is used on the job, only 3 percent-or $3.00-will contribute toward the overall recycled content value.

LEED allows for an alternate calculation method for supplementary cementitious materials such as fly ash, but the overall contribution toward the project’s total recycled material value may still be comparatively small. And even with its high recycled content, rebar alone will likely not be sufficient to achieve the 20 percent threshold for recycled content and the team will need to carefully specify other materials to meet the project’s LEED goals.

Conversely, look at a design featuring a steel-framed structure with structural studs, sheathing and metal panel façade. The structural and other steel components used in the building will likely easily constitute greater than 20 percent of the total materials cost for the project. Given the high levels of recycled content in steel, a team should be able to comply with the 20 percent threshold needed to achieve MRc4: Recycled Content. However, the extraction distance of steel products can be difficult if not impossible to obtain. Therefore, these materials often cannot contribute toward MRc5: Regional Materials, and unless careful attention is paid to the sourcing of all other building components, the team may struggle to achieve this credit.

Successful Strategies

Teams can more reliably predict their successful achievement of LEED Materials and Resources credits by implementing the following strategies:

In the end, it all comes down to a team effort. The design has to incorporate the best mix of materials; the contractor has to purchase and install the right things and all of the documentation has to be assembled in a way that is acceptable to the LEED reviewer before final certification can be awarded.

Thomas Taylor, a 29-year veteran of the construction industry and noted expert on sustainability, is the general manager of St. Louis-based Vertegy. His recent book, “Guide to LEED 2009: Estimating and Preconstruction Strategies,” provides step-by-step information about the LEED 2009 for New Construction process. To learn more about Vertegy or Taylor’s new book, visit www.vertegyconsultants.com[1] for more information.

Endnotes:
  1. www.vertegyconsultants.com: http://www.vertegyconsultants.com

Source URL: https://www.metalarchitecture.com/articles/strategies-to-achieve/