by Jonathan McGaha | February 28, 2010 12:00 am
There’s an interesting editorial in the September 2009 issue of Building Design + Construction about small AEC firms getting eaten alive by larger firms. I read it the day after attending a Society for Marketing Professional Services program where Rusty Sherwood of McGraw-Hill Construction shared his outlook for 2010 in the AEC industry, but the points made were similar.
During Sherwood’s discussion (and in the BD+C editorial), someone in the room raised the notion that larger firms are competing with smaller firms for projects and using their larger size and experience to win work that was going to smaller firms.
If you play this scenario out over time, what happens?
The larger firms will add to their backlog and look busy, but those new projects don’t bring in enough revenue to keep the lights on, desks filled and doors open, and generate adequate profits. This brings about layoffs, office shrinkage and possibly firms going out of business, or at the very least, a merger with or sale to another megafirm.
Meanwhile, in smaller firms, those projects that fit their smaller overhead structure stop coming in. That means the few people working for these small firms have nothing to do and the firm owner has little choice but to either close his doors or sell to the larger firm that is stealing their lunch.
PSMJ Resources consultant Brad Wilson, who specializes in mergers and acquisitions, sees this trend as a positive for the AEC industry.
“The industry is consolidating. It’s been way too fragmented for far too long. Little tiny firms have been beating on each other on price alone for decades, but at some point, the industry has to mature. There’s not enough room in the United States for all the A/E firms we have to be financially viable and healthy.”
Wilson uses the term “constructive destruction” to describe what is happening. “It rips the industry apart, but it’s actually a good thing. I ran across another huge example of it this week.A tiny senior living facility was up from Virginia for selection and a client of mine, another midsized firm, and a megafirm got shortlisted. The megafirm put together a complete BIM schematic, with 4-D modeling, animation with people walking through the facility and everything. They spent probably close to $200,000. Neither of the other two firms have the capability to do it, or the money to spend on it. The client was so blown away by the ‘wow’ factor that they gave it to the megafirm. Even without the expertise, big firms are throwing big dollar weight against these small projects because they can. The total fee was $2million. The megafirm would have to make 10 percent on it just to recoup their marketing dollars.What they are trying to do is build a reputation in the senior living market and chase out the little guys.
“And the client thinks, ‘If the megafirm did that much work to win our business, they must really want our work.’ I would imagine with the drawings and if they built it up right, they could have construction documents ready for the client to sign within a week or two. You collect the schematic design fee after you’ve already spent it and you’re ready to go.Meanwhile, my client has to lay off 10 more people because they didn’t get the job.”
What must happen to prevent this scenario from occurring is what is sort of playing out right now. Megafirms such as Balfour Beatty, AECOMand URS are gobbling up firms such as Parsons Brinckerhoff, Ellerbe Becket and Washington Group.
Some of this is strategic positioning on the part of the acquiring firms but there are two sides to every sale and the reason PB, Ellerbe Becket and Washington Group decided to sell is because there just isn’t enough work out there to keep them busy.
Wilson sees a future of the haves and the have-nots dominating the AEC industry. “It’s never going to get to the level of the car industry, where we have five big manufacturers dominate the world, but I think the ENR 500 and no smaller could be very much the future. It will take a very long time, but I’ve always advocated that we’re going to end up with very large firms and very small firms; the ones with principal connections in Columbus, Ohio, and can live on that and then the multinational firms who only market very big work. I’m not sure that is valid anymore, because they’re not just marketing very big work.”
If you’re wondering how large firms can afford to go after small projects given their exorbitant overhead, Wilson has a theory. Actually, two theories. “Either they (large firms) have found a better way of not allocating corporate overhead over small offices and not penalizing small offices or they are doing predatory marketing and as soon as Stantec clears out Columbus of all the legacy smaller firms, they will raise their fees. I think some of each is going on.A giant like AECOM, it is not worth their time to monkey with rates and are being predatory, but someone who is deep pocketed and smaller might be doing some of both.”
However, PSMJ Resources consultant Bill Fanning thinks this is just a temporary move on the partof large firms. “They go for the gold and right now there are no gold projects, just small stuff. They have always abandoned small project/client markets when the big stuff returns.”
Unless prospects improve (and even best-case forecasts say that while we have reached the floor of the recession, the recovery may not be here for several months and may be a jobless one at that),expect more of it in months to come.
Ed Hannan is vice president of publishing at PSMJ Resources Inc. in Newton, Mass. Details can be found at
www.psmj.com.
Source URL: https://www.metalarchitecture.com/articles/when-big-firms-play-in-small-sandboxes-its-not-necessarily-bad-news-for-everyone/
Copyright ©2026 Metal Architecture unless otherwise noted.