
Razor-thin margins, impossible schedules, cutthroat competition and unreasonable contract terms are all topics we hear discussed in our markets, and still project teams often overlook one participant in the delivery of a project that could be an ally and resource in resolving these issues-the contractor. When faced with all of these external stressors, it seems logical for an owner, developer or designer to capitalize on the combined strength of the entire team and leverage the collective knowledge of each team member. But, many delivery teams often write off the contractors as being just the muscle behind a project instead of realizing how valuable their knowledge and input could be.
As the U.S. construction market continues to struggle out of its slump, and as our industry continues to look more to sustainable designs and an increasing number of municipalities begin mandating LEED certification, it’s time for delivery teams to start acknowledging that contractors don’t always have to be just the strength behind a project.
The Master Builder
Contractors can be compared with the historical concept of the master builder. At some point in time, our industry evolved from the concept of the master builder-a person responsible for assembling a team that would carry a project from concept to completion- to a delivery method that is now viewed as an assembly of commodity-type purchases in which the lowest price takes the job. Master builders worked with owners to understand their needs and translated those needs into a design, seeking consultation and guidance from their assembled team. They took an active role in selecting each material and took the time to understand the interconnectivity of each system. Their work was not complete until they oversaw and built the structure. Those master builders knew every inch of the buildings they were responsible for delivering. In essence, these master builders utilized an integrated delivery methodology for their projects. Integrated delivery goes beyond integrated design and includes everyone who has responsibility for any part of the completed project. The list of participants can be short: owner, architect, engineer, builder; or it could be more inclusive, adding the community code officials, facility managers and end users. The size of the delivery team matters little when compared to the importance of the inclusion of the entire team.
An Influential Team Member
In previous columns, I described the importance of the integrated process and outlined the differences between integrated design and integrated delivery. Integrated design typically concludes with the production of a set of tender documents with which an owner initiates a bidding process for contractors and suppliers. Introducing the concept of integration into this process may result in a good design, but often positions the contractor to compete on the lowest common denominator: cost. Integration in the design phase only fails to recognize or reward contractors for their problem-solving abilities or their experiences.
The typical bidding process looks for a strong back and not much else-as long as the price is cheap. This is unfortunate because contractors are providers of solutions, and solving problems is what they do every day. When you add the LEED process into the mix, the contractor’s work can have a direct effect on the success of a project. Under the LEED for New Construction and Major Renovations rating system, 54 of the 100 available core points and two of the eight required prerequisites are defined as “Construction” phase, requiring documentation during or at the end of construction.
These point totals do not reflect the Innovation in Design or Regional Priority sections of the rating system, which can be either Design or Construction phase, depending on the credits selected in these categories. When the contractor has so much influence over the outcome of a LEED project, using cost as the most important element on which to base selection just doesn’t make sense. It would be more beneficial to use a different process that allows the contractor to become an active team member before the design is complete. Early inclusion of contractors allows teams to benefit from their knowledge, not just their backs.
Walking the Talk
I learned recently, however, when my team was asked by a contractor to participate in a project pursuit, that even when a project team appears eager to include a contractor early on in the process, it doesn’t always necessarily mean they will embrace the contractor’s involvement. The owner of this particular project decided to invite the contractor to be a member of the team early in the design process, and the contractor’s price was to be determined based on the fees that each contractor would charge on the previously established budget. The project goals included achieving a Platinum level LEED certification, a firm budget and a tight delivery schedule. At the pre-bid meeting, the owner gave an impassioned speech relating to the importance of teamwork.
The architects echoed those comments and stated that they enjoyed working with contractors and looked for ways to capitalize on good ideas no matter where they came from. Several contractors went through an extensive pre-qualification process and eventually, four qualified contractors were asked to submit proposals. Two of the four approached the project using their LEED experience as their key differentiator from their competition. The numbers were submitted and interviews were conducted. At the end of the process, the difference between the high and the low fee structure was negligible. The contractor that was awarded the project did not win based on experience with LEED; he had a very limited number of LEED projects under his belt. He won by demonstrating he could do what he was told, acting as a contractor and nothing more. Unfortunately, it appears the moral of the story is that just because you have a willing, knowledgeable owner and architects that say they value an integrated approach, it does not always mean people will do what they say. Like the majority of projects, this one will be built, but it could have possibly been much better if everyone on the team was selected for the strength of their brains in addition to their brawn.
Thomas Taylor, a 29-year veteran of the construction industry and noted expert on sustainability, is the general manager of St. Louis-based Vertegy. His recent book, “Guide to LEED 2009: Estimating and Preconstruction Strategies,” provides stepby- step information about the LEED 2009 for New Construction process. To learn more about Vertegy or Taylor’s new book, visit www.vertegyconsultants. com for more information.


