Features

Deconstructing Daylighting

By Administrator   From office buildings to schools and retail stores to hospitals, daylight plays an important role in a building’s design. Studies such as “Daylighting in Schools: An investigation into the relationship between daylighting and human performance,” by Pacific Gas and Electric Co., on behalf of the California Board for Energy Efficiency Third Party… Continue reading Deconstructing Daylighting
By Administrator

daylighting

 

From office buildings to schools and retail stores to hospitals, daylight plays an important role in a building’s design. Studies such as “Daylighting in Schools: An investigation into the relationship between daylighting and human performance,” by Pacific Gas and Electric Co., on behalf of the California Board for Energy Efficiency Third Party Program, show that natural sunlight boosts everything from employee morale to students’ test scores, while decreasing the length of hospital stays and increasing retail sales.

Even in the agricultural and post-frame construction markets, John C. Biehl, market manager at Palram Americas, Kutztown, Pa., notes that natural daylighting solutions come into play with a lot of buildings that are located in the middle of nowhere and are unconditioned with no electricity running to them.

“People are drawn to the sun. Everyone wants to live, work and play in places that have plenty of natural light,” says Mark Albertine, president of OpenAire Inc., Oakville, Ontario, Canada.

“Daylighting is an important element for achieving energy-efficient and sustainable design, by not only displacing the need for electric lighting during daytime hours, but also likely reducing interior cooling loads used with electric lighting,” says Neall Digert, vice president of product enterprise, Solatube International, Vista, Calif. “Daylight is critical not only from a sustainability point of view, but to the productivity, health and well-being of all human beings. All building occupants benefit on multiple levels from access to daylight.”

Daylighting Products

From windows to skylights, curtainwalls to light shelves, there are a variety of different products that
can be used for daylighting. According to the Skylight Council of the American Architectural Manufacturers Association, there are two types of daylighting products: vertical fenestration products, or side-lighting, such as windows, doors, curtainwalls and storefronts that provide light along the building’s perimeter; and overhead fenestration products, or top-lighting, such as skylights, roof windows and tubular daylighting devices that provide light from above.

“There are many different techniques and products that can be used in daylight,” says MattSnyder, sales and marketing assistant manager at Acurlite Structural Skylights Inc., Berwick, Pa. “Glass has evolved through the years and has a wide variety of different products that can be used. There are many high-performance low-E coating, different tints and frit patterns that all help improve energy performance. There is also glass available that will tint when energized. All of these products will help improve energy performance of the skylight. You can also incorporate photovoltaic panels into your skylight which allow for energy to be produced for your building.”

“In many new buildings, the design team attempts to maintain high visible light transmittance (VLT or VT) to ‘connect’ occupants to the outside, provide views and exploit natural daylighting,” says Steve Fronek, vice president of technical services at Wausau, Wis.-based Wausau Window and Wall Systems. “It is not only the amount of natural light that is important to building occupants, but also its quality, spectral composition, contrast, variability and directionality

Getting Started

Before designing a building with daylighting, there are a number of things that need to be taken into
consideration.

According to Digert, the first thing you need to do is characterize the daylight resource. Questions
to ask include: What percentage of the day is there sun? Are the skies partially overcast? What’s the
path of the sun? What’s happening with the seasons? Is there snow on the ground and roof? Shade
from trees or nearby buildings? “These factors will determine your daylighting solutions, as well as
façade articulation,” Digert says.

Gary DiFazio, director of sales at Palram Americas, notes that is important to know what type of
light that is going to be transmitted in a daylighting system. Is it a diffused light or a shaded light? Is heat build-up a concern?

Digert explains that a daylighting system should be designed to control contrast ratios within the occupied, daylit areas. “This means determining the proper placement and control of the daylight relative to the brightness of glazing elements and adjacent/ surrounding architectural surfaces and elements,” he says. From there, it is important to minimize shifting patterns of sunlight within the interior to avoid causing severe glare.

“Daylight-responsive electric lighting controls are an essential element to any daylighting system. After all, no daylighting design will save any energy unless the electric lights are dimmed or turned off when there is sufficient illumination from daylight,” says Jaime Nachbar, marketing and business development at CPI Daylighting Inc., Lake Forest, Ill. “An active/dynamic daylighting system-whether a skylight or one used in a vertical application-that can dynamically manage the desired sunlight transmission and shading inside the space, based on the sun position, is the most effective daylighting system.”

“With traditional daylighting, the building orientation will drive the daylighting design,” says Digert. “With new optical technology, the orientation becomes far less important. When employing tubular daylighting device systems, you can apply apertures where they make sense without being overly concerned about the architecture. The system is designed independent of the building’s orientation.”

“In general, south-facing windows let in the most light-and also the most heat gain,” says Mark Mitchell, marketing manager at Major Industries Inc., Wausau, Wis. “Translucent systems can help control the heat gain, though it is sometimes welcomed in colder climates to offset heating costs in winter. With the variety of daylighting systems available to today’s designers, building orientation is less and less of a problem, and more of a challenge. Careful positioning, minimizing support structures underneath a skylight, and even sloped ceilings can help direct more sunlight into a space.”

“Sunlight availability is set by site, neighboring buildings and façade orientation,” Fronek explains. “The sun’s path is low in the winter and high in the summer.” He continues on, saying that daylight availability changes across the day and throughout the year. To realize the full benefits of daylighting, windows should face north or south; east and west-facing windows should be avoided or minimized; and interior surfaces must help distribute the daylight into the space.

Keys for Success

“The most successful daylighting system is one that’s custom-designed for the usage of the space, and isn’t just a one-size-fits-all solution,” Mitchell explains. “You also have to weigh the benefits of natural light with any solar heat gain or heat loss that may occur–which can be minimized by using a system that allows for insulation options and one that minimizes heat gain.”

Albertine notes that one of the biggest challenges with daylighting is maintaining comfortable temperatures. “Heat loss through windows can be a problem in the winter, and in summer, the sun can raise temperatures to uncomfortably high levels.”

It is important to adhere to the guidelines set by the International Energy Conservation Code and ASHRAE, as well as utilizing products tested per the National Fenestration Rating Council protocol, says Nachbar. “Daylighting products need to be selected based on performance, application and longevity. To select products solely on cost is guaranteed to cost a great deal more money in the long run.”

“In new construction, the sky’s the limit,” DiFazio says. “You can design whatever the customer likes because you have the flexibility in terms of what the building spans are, the types of materials used as far as skinning, what colors the customer wants, whether to use ridgelights, sidelights or skylights. All of these factors can come into play. You can design in whatever type of daylighting you want based on the individual building codes in an area and what the customer wants.”

Digert says it is important to look at the building as an integrated system, thinking about the daylight application and how it affects other decisions relative to other building and architectural systems.

“A successfully daylit building is the result of a combination of art and science, of architecture and engineering,” Nachbar explains. “It is the result of an integrated design process, and is not simply a technology that is installed once the building is complete.

“Even with proven metrics, daylighting will always be a mix of art and science, of logical thinking and common sense. Climate and geographical region, building type and use and building orientation are big factors in designing a successfully daylit building. Designers must always apply basic lighting and building performance principles to successfully employ daylighting.”

Tips for Retrofitting

While the sky may be the limit when it comes to designing a new building with daylighting, there
are a number of things that need to be taken into consideration when it comes to adding daylighting to an existing building.

“In a retrofit, the building may define where you can and can’t add daylighting,” states Neall Digert,
vice president of product enterprise, Solatube International, Vista, Calif. “However, the new optical technologies greatly reduce the structural limitations on how daylighting can be effectively applied. Products such as tubular daylighting devices can be reconfigured over time as the building gets reconfigured.”

Jaime Nachbar, marketing and business development at CPI Daylighting Inc., Lake Forest, Ill., offers
up some questions that should be asked about an existing building to determine the best way to add daylighting. They are:

  • What is the building’s current percent of daylighting?
  • Is the percentage of light currently below the International Energy Conservation Code building code requirement?
  • Is the building too dark or does it have too much daylight and glare?
  • Does the existing glazing meet the minimum IECC building code and is it high performance glazing?
  • What is the specific performance of the fenestration product (skylight, window wall or curtain wall) for SHGC, U-value and visible transmission (VT)?
  • What is the most cost-effective way to add daylighting- skylights, curtainwalls or window walls?
  • And what (if any) daylighting products are currently being used?

Rod Kivioja, director of sales at Super Sky Products Enterprises LLC, Mequon, Wis., notes that when it comes to adding daylighting to an existing building it is important to keep in mind the building construction and load capabilities of the structure, keeping space watertight during demolition and installation, the existing HVAC capabilities and budget constraints.

Matt Snyder, sales and marketing assistant manager at Acurlite Structural Skylights Inc., Berwick, Pa., agrees, saying: “A couple of things need to be looked at. First, can the existing building handle the new loads from the skylight? Second, can the existing HVAC system handle the new loads required to cool or heat the space? Also, if the building is occupied, how will construction affect the tenants?”

“In the case of a skylight, the adequacy of the support structure has to be taken into account when retrofitting-especially when adding a lot of weight, as is the case with glass skylights,” explains Mark Mitchell, marketing manager at Major Industries Inc., Wausau, Wis. “Translucent panel skylights tend to be easier to add to existing structures because they are lighter in weight, thus requiring less support, which in turn costs the building owner less in construction costs.”

Whether adding daylighting to an existing building or designing a building from the ground up, the most important thing is to consult with daylighting manufacturers to find the right solution for your project.