Columns

Contractual Considerations of LEED

Recently, I was asked by a general contractor to review proposed contract language for a project in which LEED certification was to be pursued. The purpose of the review was to provide comment on any items that could increase the contractor’s liability and identify areas of assigned responsibility that might add cost to the “General… Continue reading Contractual Considerations of LEED

Usgbc Logo 01

Recently, I was asked by a general contractor to review proposed contract language for a project in which LEED certification was to be pursued. The purpose of the review was to provide comment on any items that could increase the contractor’s liability and identify areas of assigned responsibility that might add cost to the “General Conditions” portion of the contractor’s bid. My firm has performed this activity many times over the past six years, and this task gives us the opportunity to see firsthand how owners are responding to the evolving legalities of LEED.

 

Roles and Responsibilities

Each member of the team, including the owner, architect, engineer, contractor and end user, has a part in the delivery of a project that will one day receive LEED certification. Because of this, it is vitally important that those involved in the delivery of LEED projects understand their roles and responsibilities. The project I recently reviewed was a lump sum general contract in which the contractor had no responsibility for the design of the project. In the terms and conditions section of the contract, the language related to LEED certification led the reader to believe that the owner may not have been fully aware of which members of the delivery team were responsible for the various activities required on a LEED project. The first indication of this came with the following statement:

 

Contractor shall have on staff a LEED Accredited Professional who has experience in constructing LEED certified projects and shall, as requested by the owner, administer the LEED certification process using its best efforts to cooperate with architect and assist the owner to achieve the desired LEED certification for the project.

When we see proposed contractual language such as this, several questions must be asked, including:

  • What is the owner’s definition of cooperation?
  • How much effort will it take to assist the owner in achieving the desired level of LEED certification?

The terms cooperate and assist can take on a variety of different meanings depending on whom you ask. These terms can also take on a different meaning depending on the phase of the project. At the start of most projects, there is generally an optimistic feeling among the entire team that everything related to the project is going to work out as exactly planned. As the project moves from design to construction, budgets are tested, value-engineering exercises are required, schedules are sometimes disrupted and the drivers of the project shift. How an owner defines cooperation and assistance at the beginning of a project can change drastically when faced with the extreme stressors that often occur at the end of a project. A practical approach to alleviate potential problems that could arise with the use of vague terms such as cooperate and
assist is to specify the exact activities that will be required by the contractor or to provide an allowance of hours that may be expended to assist the owner with LEED-related tasks.

LEED and Contract Documents

During our recent review of contract language, the second red flag went up when we read the following:

 

Contractor shall perform the work in accordance with the LEED checklist to the extent that such checklist and criteria therein are consistent with the requirements of the contract documents, including but not limited to LEED criteria which relate to procurement of materials, on-site installation practices and construction waste management.

 

This type of proposed contract language is problematic for a variety of reasons. One of the main issues involves using a LEED checklist as a contract document. A LEED checklist should be used as a tracking tool, not a basis of contractor performance. A LEED checklist indicates the prerequisites and credits contained in the LEED rating system and provides information regarding the credits that are anticipated to be achieved by the specific project. A checklist may also indicate whether the prerequisite or credit is defined as a Design or Construction phase submittal by USGBC. This last piece of information, if included on the checklist, can create challenges for project teams. USGBC designates prerequisites and credits as either “Design” or “Construction” phase. These designations provide a guide as to who may be responsible for the documentation of those corresponding prerequisites and credits. While the designations generally provide an accurate depiction of when the prerequisite or credit can be documented, assigning full responsibility of a prerequisite or credit based on this designation is not always a perfect fit. Therefore, it is critical for contractors preparing lump sum cost proposals for projects seeking LEED certification to understand all of the requirements of the LEED rating system.

The following example illustrates the potential issues which can arise from assigning sole responsibility for a LEED prerequisite or credit to one project team member. Energy and Atmosphere Prerequisite 1 delineates specific requirements for fundamental commissioning of the building energy systems. USGBC designates this prerequisite as a Construction phase submittal. The inference from this designation is that the contractor is responsible for commissioning the building energy systems. However, further examination of the LEED Reference Guide reveals that the first of twelve individual steps required to comply with this prerequisite is that the Commissioning Authority (the person responsible for the commissioning activities) be designated during the design phase of the project. In all, six of the twelve required steps for compliance with the commissioning prerequisite must take place before the start of the construction phase of the project. USGBC provides further guidance that if a project is larger than 50,000 square feet, a member of the contractor’s team cannot carry out the commissioning activities. While the checklist may indicate that this prerequisite is a Construction phase submittal, and it is true that the contractor must take an active role in the commissioning process, it is clear that the responsibility starts with the design team.

Read the Contract-and the LEED Requirements!

The proposed contract language I recently reviewed went on to include many other examples of these types of issues-many more than I am able to cover here. The point is that when it comes to providing lump sum bids for projects that are pursuing LEED certification, proposing contractors would be wise to understand the extent of the responsibilities to which they are obligating themselves. Contractors are often reminded to “RTC”-Read the Contract! In the case of a LEED project, it is equally important to read the LEED requirements and understand how they may become a part of your contract documents, unless you take steps to make sure your scope of work carefully and explicitly defines your LEED role.

—

Thomas Taylor, a 29-year veteran of the construction industry and noted expert on sustainability, is the general manager of St. Louis-based Vertegy, a sustainability consultancy firm that was launched in February 2005 following the success of the LEED Platinum Alberici Corporate Headquarters. His recent book,
Guide to LEED 2009: Estimating and Preconstruction Strategies, provides step-by-step information about the LEED 2009 for New Construction process. Vertegy provides clients with design, procurement and construction consulting services for green and sustainable facilities. To learn more about Vertegy or Thomas’ new book, visit
www.vertegyconsultants.com
for more information.