Don’t fall prey to the pitfalls of project management
Effective project management requires doing something that not everyone is comfortable with; can be very painful; and takes a lot of time and energy (sometimes away from what you would rather be doing). Yes, we must admit, working with other people is not always the easiest part of a project. For some architects, their strengths lie in imagining and creating a brilliant design, not so much in bringing all the parties involved together to make that design work.
Today’s projects often involve more entities than ever before with owners, investors, government agencies, contractors and other stakeholders all having a hand and a say in how things should run. Being the project manager requires lots of work, communication, organization, scheduling and integration. It’s not the kind of thing that can be done on the fly and it means having a grasp on every aspect of a project, not just the design.
How do you manage it all?
Have a Plan
Steven Isaacs is the division manager of Architecture and Engineering Consulting Services for FMI, provider of management consulting, investment banking and research to the design and construction industry. Isaacs has been both an engineer and president of an architectural firm. He teaches project management to practicing architects, and one thing he can’t stress enough is that you must have a plan.
“A plan is made up of a group of items, having a goal for the project, what you’re trying to achieve, what the client is trying to achieve,” Isaacs explained. “A plan includes how a project team is going to work together, working towards a budget, schedules—who do I have to count on, when do I bring them in, what are the tools I’m going to use (BIM or not BIM)?”
“The second part is if you have a plan, it has to be alive. You have to monitor the plan, you have to adjust the plan. I find so many project managers who are good enough to have a plan then don’t go and look at the plan again.”
As basic as the idea of a plan may seem, Isaacs said architects often have no shortage of excuses for why they haven’t come up with one: the project is too small, they don’t have time, they can’t plan well because they’re not going to get the staffing they need.
“When I ran an architectural firm, I always said, ‘no plan, no staff,’” Isaacs said. “Everyone says, ‘I gotta get started.’ The answer is, ‘Get started on what if you don’t know where you’re going?’ This is like starting a journey without looking at a map.”
Getting Started
So how do you get started rather than just talking about it?
Stephen Wakeman is a design principal with Jacobs in Arlington, Va. Wakeman, who works with metal on almost every project he’s involved in, said the very beginning stages are among the most important.
“As soon as we determine it’s going to be metal, we’re getting the correct forms and sizes. The one thing I look for with the architectural team is that they’ve got to understand the material,” Wakeman said. Included in that, he said, is looking for ways to minimize any waste of material.
Wakeman said you need an appropriate manufacturer and technical team that can help you work through what the material can and cannot do, and find ways to be innovative.
The next step is making sure you can control the budget on a project, Wakeman said. Many of Jacobs’ projects are through the government, which means a certain amount of money has been allotted and the firm can’t go over that amount.
“We have to work with the guys who install it and understand the cost,” Wakeman said. “The whole team has to understand it.”
Wakeman’s experience is a good example of the many facets a project manager has to have under his or her control: working as a team with the design principal, creating a schedule and budget while interfacing with the client, and understanding the material and construction variables that will affect the final product.
“You’re pretty much on the same page from the get-go,” he said. “Once we’ve made key decisions, we stick with it and get to the finish line. We have to be pretty efficient. Most of our clients are excited to get into a new facility, and our team is energized from week one to get the team on a united front to get them there.”
Why It’s So Hard
Project management may sound simple enough, but talking to people who have done it, you get the sense it’s far from easy. In fact, it in some cases it’s a bit of a battle, one that starts within the architectural firm.
ZweigWhite, a provider of business management services for architecture, engineering and environmental consulting firms, has been collecting data on project management through yearly surveys since 1998. Recently, according to ZweigWhite Project Management Professional and Principal Christine Brack, there have been some unnerving trends.
According to the survey data, architecture firms aren’t keeping track of rework, they’re promoting inexperienced project managers and not sharing enough information with the project team.
“Likely the dip in all that probably comes from the past few years, there being a shortage of good project managers and shortage of fairly experienced engineers and architects,” Brack said. “Firms were worried if they educate and train a project manager too much, they’ll just go to another firm with all this knowledge. They were concentrating on fear rather than just being a good firm to work for.”
Brack said younger personnel see the project manager position as a better role, possibly offering more perks and salary, and principals see it as a way to keep good young people at their firms. However, the principal often ends up not having time to monitor the newly minted project manager, who ends up making a series of mistakes.
“The economy didn’t help either,” Brack said. “A lot of firms had to really skinny down. Maybe the principals managed a little more, or people had to do trial by fire.”
Meanwhile, according to Brack, there is the issue of a given firm’s culture, which sometimes prevents the sharing of information.
“You might have a project manager who knows the good tenets of project management. There will be no success in a project if you’re only working with half the information,” Brack said. “If you’re working with leadership who doesn’t share that information you’re not going to go anywhere. Good project management has to be pushed from the top.”
Unfortunately, according to Brack, leadership sometimes guards that information like a big secret.
“They don’t want people to know billing rates, the contract amount with the fee … some firms don’t even want the PM to have direct contact with the client,” she said. “I suspect they’re keeping that information from the project manager because they’re just afraid of something. It doesn’t make sense in a business way.
“Where most project managers run into some trouble is if right from the get-go you don’t establish how the role is defined and what the responsibilities are—things will fall through the cracks. Some PMs are not responsible for the profit and loss. At that point, you’re just a glorified expediter. A PM has to have full responsibility for the project from start to finish. You just can’t make good informed decisions if you don’t have the information or the authority.”
Another issue that creates problems in project management is one that Isaacs said is all too prevalent— conflict avoidance.
“I think project managers sometimes don’t face the issues at the right time,” Isaacs said. “They see it as such a difficult issue that they put it on the back burner, thinking if they just leave it, it will get better. A lot of these issues are like fish—if you catch a fish and you leave it out, very soon it will start to smell, and the longer you leave it out the more it will smell.
“It can take an easily solvable problem and make it much more difficult. Somehow we are so ingrained with being service oriented that we have confused that with meaning to be good service people we have to avoid conflict. To be good service people, we have to help everyone face conflict. This is a confusion that’s been going on since I’ve been in the industry. Service includes working together on resolving conflict no matter how it comes up.”
Making it Work
Brack said that from an architectural perspective, a good project manager needs to divorce him or herself from the design side.
“A project needs to have a leader on it,” Brack said. “For a PM, most of their time is spent communicating. If that PM is focusing too much on design, you’re not growing the team underneath you. You need to be spending your time orchestrating. For an architect, the design is never done. If they had unlimited time they’d be overdesigning or thinking about the possibilities endlessly. The PM duties, the paperwork, the answering will fall to the wayside. Not intentionally, but that’s generally what happens.”
Architecture firms can farm out the project management duties, but Brack said this means losing out on a potential revenue source, and that there is no reason they can’t do it in-house if the project manager is given the combination of information, authority and responsibility that make the position work.
Isaacs said that in order to be a good project manager in today’s marketplace, you have to go beyond the basics of budgeting and scheduling. While those things are important too, you have to be almost like a coach bringing a team together. It’s the ability to be in constant collaboration, negotiation and communication with a diverse group of stakeholders that make for a successful project manager.
Project managers must also, perhaps more than ever, be prepared to face uncertainty and have a broader perspective.
“They have to be prepared to be flexible to work with clients on these difficult problems,” Isaacs said. “Today a project is funded, tomorrow it’s funded by half. To be able to handle these problems is an incredible request of PMs today. I believe it’s going to take a new level of training and a new level of skills that is not one of the strengths of the industry. We have to train ourselves, we have to have PMs that are better read. They have to understand what’s going on beyond the project. Add to that globalization and you’ve just squared the problem.
“When a butterfly flaps its wings in the Amazon, how does it change the environment in the Arctic? They have to be prepared to face that on a regular basis.”
Metal and Project Management
According to Stephen Wakeman, design principal with Jacobs in Arlington, Va., the use of metal on a project can be very helpful. Often working on federally funded projects, Wakeman said his clients’ biggest concern is often whether or not the roof will leak. The low- to no-maintenance requirements of metal roofs, allows him to assure them that will not be a problem and that, in general, the roof won’t be a concern for many years. “You design something with metal, you pretty much know the install price of it,” Wakeman said, his point being that metal takes the guess work out of a project. The sizes, installation and functionality are known quantities. The product usually arrives in a neat kit of parts, cutting down on waste (not only of materials, but of time). Metal also provides sustainability and is innovative enough to be adjusted to what a particular client wants without creating conflicts related to size, form or cost.


