Features

Roundtable on Metal Building Systems

By Paul Deffenbaugh MA: Why should an architect or specifier choose to utilize a metal building system instead of more “traditional” materials? Jeff White, President, Garco Building Systems: Ease of erecting, more economical, life span of structure, lower maintenance costs, energy savings with reflective coatings, flexibility of design. Wes Brooker, Marketing & Development Manager, American… Continue reading Roundtable on Metal Building Systems
By Paul Deffenbaugh

MA: Why should an architect or specifier choose to utilize a metal building system instead of more “traditional” materials?

Jeff White, President, Garco Building Systems: Ease of erecting, more economical, life span of structure, lower maintenance costs, energy savings with reflective coatings, flexibility of design.

Wes Brooker, Marketing & Development Manager, American Buildings Co.: The answer is simple: reduced risk and growth. There is no question that metal building and conventional construction speak two entirely different languages. Even erectors comfortable in either conventional or metal building construction don’t cross those lines very often.

Architects tend to be much more involved with “traditional” building materials as this currently represents a larger segment of the overall market and is what is primarily taught at the university level. Traditional construction involves bringing together a wide number of related and unrelated products and trades to produce the shell of a building.

There is less inherent risk for an architect or specifier working with a metal building manufacturer as responsibility for meeting local building codes, execution of unique designs and overall building performance becomes a team effort. Metal building manufacturers can draw upon experience with a wide range of similar buildings to ensure design performance. Keep in mind national metal building manufacturers often have research and development departments and sell more than 2,000 buildings annually. This means that over a five year period a manufacturer can draw upon experience from more than 10,000-plus erected buildings.

In addition to design performance, the other risk issue is time. Once a building is designed and engineered, it can be manufactured and erected quickly. Even large buildings can be manufactured in less than three weeks and erected in less than 60 days.

Joe Edge, President, Star Building Systems: The line between so called “traditional materials” and steel systems is becoming very blurred. In fact, a case could be made that steel systems are now a very traditional way to build since we capture such a large percentage of the low-rise market. If I were an architect, I would be looking for the construction materials and methods that give my client the most cost-effective solution to meet his needs. Quite often, that would be steel systems construction. Efficient computer design, flexibility, structural integrity, factory labor in lieu of field labor, outstanding quality, product life, warranties and speed of construction all come together to give the end customer a building that he can enjoy and be proud of for years and years.

Brad Robeson,President, NCI Metal Buildings Division: Steel building solutions can offer a variety of benefits, including easier on-site erection to expedite construction and speed up occupancy, and greater life cycle cost savings in many cases. Depending on the product mix, metal building systems can also contribute towards a building project with greater energy efficiency and LEED-friendly construction.

MA: Metal buildings are often overlooked when it comes to design and architecture. What sort of customization is available for metal building systems?

White: The customization of metal buildings is endless— masonry, block, tile, glass, tilt up, drivit, curved roof accents and interfacing with conventional construction.

Brooker: Metal building systems are constructed in many different shapes and sizes for many applications, including manufacturing and distribution centers, retail and commercial facilities, offices and schools, recreation centers and self-storage facilities, religious buildings, health care and correctional institutions.

Metal building companies offer a variety of building styles, framing styles, column shapes and girt conditions that can satisfy virtually all building requirements. Nonload- bearing walls permit wide clear span interiors unobstructed by interior columns. Interior layout possibilities of metal building systems are practically unlimited, enabling utmost flexibility for workflow or storage requirements. And metal building systems can be readily combined with traditional building materials as brick, stone, glass or wood to meet any appearance requirement.

Robeson: There are few limitations on the extent to which a metal building system can be customized to meet unique architectural requirements. Over the years, NCI’s companies have produced a variety of structures that have been recognized, both in the construction industry and beyond, for their impressive design accomplishments.

Our portfolio of projects include attractive and functional solutions for such unique end-use applications as schools, churches, baseball stadiums and museums—all structures that command a special, aesthetically pleasing appearance, in addition to structural integrity. It is unfortunate that metal solutions are still sometimes misperceived as not being adaptable to individual design concepts, when in fact, metal buildings enable original possibilities for exceptional design that are both flexible and cost efficient.

MA: Given the state of the construction industry and overall economy, are metal buildings a viable market segment that architects and designers can add to their portfolios? What makes it attractive?

White: They are most definitely a viable market segment that both architects and designers are adding to their portfolios. Both groups understand that there is a cost savings in using a steel building system. That the building will be shipped as a package with their erection drawings and the erectability of the building is costing them far less in labor and frustration than that of a conventional building. That the steel product will be a sustainable product and the structure has as many options for exterior aesthetics as conventional construction.

Brooker: The flexibility of metal building systems allows the industry to adapt quickly to what construction opportunities are available. During the recession of 2001-03 many companies learned how to engineer and manufacture schools which was quite radical prior to that time. Last year, the greatest construction crash in our lifetime, the metal building industry almost doubled its involvement in government construction from 15 to 28 percent. This is a tough hard bid market and certainly not the first choice for many but there were few options.

As long as private owners and government agencies want buildings that reduce construction time, construction costs and maintenance costs without compromising quality, there will be a market for metal building systems.

Edge: Yes, speed, flexibility, durability, integrity of design, beauty, and of course cost.

MA: How are metal building systems evolving to meet the wants and needs of potential customers?

White: Metal building system’s have always been more customer friendly than conventional construction. It has taken some time to get that message to the potential end-users of our building systems, but we believe that message is being heard and are finding that residential may be the last market segment to get on board.

Brooker: Since every building is custom, the nature of the business is to meet the needs and wants of existing and potential customers on a daily basis. Design changes take place real time and if a company doesn’t stay up to date or look forward the future will be bleak.

Military, schools and corporate owners are committed to metal roofing with cool coatings as they are one-third the cost of conventional flat roof systems over a 36-year period. Life expectancy for standing-seam metal roof systems with PVDF cool coatings are in excess of 50 years.

We anticipate potential customers will be demanding much more energy-efficient structures utilizing increased insulation, minimal air infiltration, natural lighting and improved HVAC systems. In some cases our current wall and roof assemblies will have to change to meet these demands.

Edge: The evolution of steel systems has been dramatic. From unpainted tool sheds or “dog houses” for the oilfields, we have been transformed to beautiful industrial, retail, municipal and church buildings that incorporate brick, stone, wood and every other construction material imaginable. At the same time we are complying with ever-changing and increasingly stringent code requirements.

MA: What will the metal building systems market look like two to three years from now?

White: The metal building systems market should be steady and growing stronger in the next two to three years. Being part of a larger piece of the pie (NCI Group) only makes our building systems more attractive in every aspect from pricing, to product choices, to R&D using our multi-brand approach. The opportunity is out there and we will make use of our resources to make these next few years and the future stronger than ever. We think that much of the next few years we will see market increases in government type work, hospitals, school systems, with an emphasis on sustainability. We are seeing many more reroof opportunities affected by stimulus money, as well.

Brooker: It depends upon whether the United States and Canada wake up to the fact that if we don’t get our manufacturing base back our lives will continue to change for the worse. We have proven in spades that the “service” economy will not sustain us economically and that it can be outsourced in a nanosecond to other parts of the world. We have to start creating products people want to buy and build plants in which to make them. Failing that we will continue building primarily for the government.

Conditioned space buildings will need to become much more energy efficient and will happen much faster than which many in the industry are comfortable. A significant advantage the metal building industry has over conventional construction is that it controls the entire envelope, making adjustment to new tougher energy and lighting standards easier. This avoids the “Keystone Cops” syndrome in conventional construction where everyone in the supply chain points at someone else for the envelope not performing.

Edge: We are optimistic that by that time activity will return to the level of business experienced in 2008.

Robeson: While no single person or entity can say with certainty what the state of the market will be in a few years, I can say that under normal, non-recessionary market conditions, there is no reason that the metal buildings industry should not be able to meet, if not surpass, our previous levels of performance.

With each passing year, greater numbers of architects, building contractors, developers and engineers are growing increasingly aware of the superior advantages that metal building solutions can provide. This shift in marketplace perceptions, coupled with the fact that the metal building industry accounts for a relatively small percentage of the overall U.S. construction market, means there are tremendous opportunities for the metal buildings market to grow, thrive and ultimately reach unprecedented levels of activity.