You don’t have to look very hard to find stories of A/E firms closing their doors, laying off employees or selling to a megafirm.
That being said, even in one of the worst economies we’ve seen in our lifetime, there are success stories out there among small and mid-sized firms.
Take, for example, the 230-person civil, structural and environmental engineering firm Alfred Benesch & Co., Chicago. Over the past year and a half, the firm:
•Successfully transitioned firm leadership.
•Transitioned from one finance and accounting system to another
(Advantage to Deltek Vision).
•Grew from 198 people to 230 people.
•Increased its net revenue per full-time employee from $128,000 to
$138,000.
•Grew a sizable backlog while most other firm backlogs are declining.
We spoke with John Carrato, president and CEO of the 63-year-old company, to find out what the firm is doing right and here is what he had to say.
Transitioning Leadership
There were four corporate officers leading the company prior to the transition to the fifth generation of leadership in 2008. “We’ve transitioned the president to me and COO to Jack Kweder. We eliminated the position of CFO by assigning those duties to the CEO. Antoine Karam is staying in his role of corporate business development and Muthiah Kasi, the former COO, will continue to serve as chairman of the board. Michael Goodkind, the former president, is serving as an executive vice president in corporate development. All three are still serving on the board of directors,” Carrato said.
The transition took place over a two-year period where in the first year, everyone stayed in their then-current roles, but the incoming leadership was involved in the decision-making process. In the second year, which is just coming to a close, the new leaders were in their roles and the former leaders served as advisors. “We work very much in a team environment,” Carrato said. “The transition has been harmonious. Of course, it always helps when the company is doing well. There’s a lot of mutual respect among the leaders.”
The company benefits from the long tenures of its leaders. Carrato is in his 29th year with Alfred Benesch. Jack Kweder, COO, is in his 30th year. Kevin Fitzpatrick, who took Carrato’s role as Chicago division manager, has been with the company for a quarter century. Greg Brennan who took over Kweder’s role as Pottsville division manager has been with the company for 29 years. In fact, Kweder and Carrato have both served on the board of directors for 15 years.
“We believe we’ve gotten past the ‘take the money and run’ mentality. As we continue to age as a firm, we’ve set a goal to achieve a more distributed ownership. That’s a self-fulfilling thing after a while. You don’t have two or three or four or five people who own 65 percent of the firm where it’s tempting to sell the firm.”
Growing the Firm
“We are very successful in getting work. We were successful going into this transition and we continue to be successful. Our numbers continue to go up. Confirming that we are a practice-centered business was helpful. It makes our decision-making process easier when it comes to deciding what types of projects to pursue. It also helps us attract talented people because we are able to clearly articulate the culture and values of the company. Our whole approach to business is building enduring relationships with our clients and having quality employees. You can do the job, but if you don’t do the job well, you aren’t getting a second job. We put a very high premium on doing quality work. Because of the quality work we do, and the people we’ve been able to bring in, we’ve been out there winning our fair share of new work.”
To do that, Carrato said the firm has ramped up its business development efforts. “In the past, when we got busy, our business development efforts slowed. We’re making a concerted effort to change that philosophy. We’re trying to increase our business development efforts while we’re strong and at the same time ensure that we have the capacity to perform the work.”
Growing Backlog
Because 85 percent of the firm’s work is in the transportation market, most of it in the public sector, Alfred Benesch has done a good job of fortifying its backlog. “I believe the firms in the transportation sector have had a little more opportunity than the people who are completely private. We’ve seen a lot of firms who do work for developers just shrivel up,” Carrato said. “We were fortunate to build a good backlog before the downturn came.”
Conclusion
Carrato believes the firm’s strategic planning process helped the firm get to where it is today. “We’re trying to look at the big picture and what provides stability for our employees in the long run. We need to be more diverse with our practice areas. The more diverse we are, the better positioned we will be to weather economic downturns.”
“For us, our people are everything. One of the things that came out of the strategic planning process was that we tried to put down in words what our core values were. We arranged them by client, company, and employee, with the thought that without our clients, there’s no company; without our company, there’s no employees; and without the relationships forged by our employees that create confidence in their abilities, there are no clients. Quality clients and talented employees are what make our company successful.”
Ed Hannan is vice president of publishing at PSMJ Resources Inc. in Newton, Mass. Details can be found at www.psmj.com.


