Columns

Building Codes

Just about anyone working in the architectural, engineering or construction industries has had to deal with building codes at some point. We began dealing with code issues more than 5,000 years ago when Hammurabi, founder of the Babylonian Empire, created the Code of Hammurabi. While Hammurabi’s code was much more stringent than we see today… Continue reading Building Codes

Just about anyone working in the architectural, engineering or construction industries has had to deal with building codes at some point. We began dealing with code issues more than 5,000 years ago when Hammurabi, founder of the Babylonian Empire, created the Code of Hammurabi. While Hammurabi’s code was much more stringent than we see today (including the death penalty for building a house that collapsed on the owner), there are penalties for professionals who choose not to follow them. A building code is a set of rules that specifies the minimum acceptable level of safety for constructed structures. The main purpose of building codes is to protect public health, safety and general welfare as they relate to the construction and occupancy of buildings. In order for a building code to become law, it must be adopted by a body that has jurisdiction and must be enforceable by the appropriate authorities.

Green Building Codes

One of the hot trends in the green building marketplace is green building codes, or incorporating sustainable or green features into the local building codes. These green building codes essentially create laws that require a certain level of sustainability in every newly constructed or renovated structure. While it is obvious that we need to change the way we have gone about our business in the past if future generations are going to have anything left to build with, green building codes are not necessarily the best way to accomplish this change. There are several reasons why green building codes could do more harm than good.

Relating Codes to Sustainability

While the purpose of a building code is to protect public health, safety and general welfare, it is often difficult to relate sustainable building practices to the protection of the public. For example, using a high amount of recycled content in building materials or utilizing locally manufactured building products does not really safeguard public health or safety. Some green building aspects relate in a very general way to public safety. For instance, green buildings are generally more energy efficient, and if less energy is consumed, then less energy needs to be generated. The result is lower pollution and emission levels, which promotes some level of public health and welfare. Additionally, it could be argued that mechanical systems with high filtration levels, a practice common in green buildings, provide the building occupants with higher quality breathable air, promoting their health and welfare. However, it is much harder to make this connection with the use of light-colored paving materials in parking lots and nearly all other green building attributes.

Most municipalities are struggling to operate within their current budgets. Adding these green elements to building codes will add to the burden of already overworked building inspectors. Green building elements, products, systems and equipment are all quickly evolving, and there are new products that enter the marketplace every day. It is not easy to keep up with the changes and even harder to understand how the combination of these elements fits to an overall sustainable strategy. A green building code would require a much deeper understanding of the sustainable strategy and the science of a building, adding to the complexity of the inspector’s review process. Those who thought it was tough to get a building permit in the old days haven’t seen anything yet!

Enforcement of Green Building Codes Enforcement of the green elements in a building code presents another potential hurdle. Most municipalities are simply not prepared to enforce sustainable practices. Rejecting an occupancy permit for life safety violations is easily understandable and enforceable. Equally clear is a municipality refusing a permit to a building team that has not made proper accommodations for disabled individuals. It would be much more difficult, however, for a municipality to refuse an occupancy permit to a building team that did not use certified wood or did not install a water-saving showerhead. There are some proposed energy codes that would require building owners to prove the energy efficiency of their buildings one year after beneficial occupancy. In this situation, it is assumed that building owners would be granted a temporary occupancy permit, and one year after move in, they would report their energy use. It is unclear what would happen in this situation if a building did not achieve the targeted energy efficiency levels. Would the building be condemned? Would the building owner receive a fine? Would the occupancy permit be revoked? The implications of these potential actions are far-reaching and impactful.

Codes and Responsibility

Issues of responsibility surrounding the design and construction of a building further complicate green building. Most construction companies performing traditional design-bid-build projects know that their price can only include what is in the plans and specifications. If they add something more than what is in the plans and specs, they probably will not be the successful bidder on that job because their bid will be higher than the other bidders who included only what was in the plans and specs. In design-bid-build jobs, it is assumed that the design team has included all the elements necessary to result in a code-compliant building. However, those same contract documents will inevitably state that it is the contractor’s responsibility to assure that all work is conducted in accordance with local, state and federal laws. Once a municipality formally adopts a building code and has the jurisdiction to enforce the code, it becomes law. If the design team does not include something in the design that is required by code, it becomes the contractor’s responsibility to provide the missing element. Making sure the proper amount of recycled content or rapidly renewable material is used in the project should not be the responsibility of the design-bid-build contractor. Likewise, it should not be the responsibility of anyone other than the design engineers to figure out if the myriad of factors, which combine and interact to result in the building’s energy use, will meet the efficiency level required by a new green building code. These factors, which affect a building’s energy efficiency and cross lines of disciplinary responsibility include:

  • Building envelope
  • Mechanical system
  • Interior and exterior lighting levels
  • Occupant determined plug load (computers, printers, monitors, kitchen equipment, portable heaters, etc.)

 

Most people would benefit from some direction when trying to figure out how to implement green strategies for a building project, and the world would probably be a better place if all building design, construction and renovation were done with a high level of sustainability. Having a mechanism in place to measure the sustainable effort would also be beneficial. However, a local, state or federal agencyenacted law requiring sustainability would likely create a much greater hardship on project teams already struggling to incorporate green attributes into their projects. Additionally, with local governments experiencing unprecedented budget deficits, the increased workload placed on inspectors by a green building code would further slow the permitting process, creating another obstacle to overcome before the building industry can successfully recover.

Thomas Taylor, a 29-year veteran of the construction
industry and noted expert on sustainability, is the general manager of St. Louis-based Vertegy. His recent book, “Guide to LEED 2009: Estimating and Preconstruction Strategies,” provides step-by-step information about the LEED 2009 for New Construction process. To learn more about Vertegy or Taylor’s new book, visit www.vertegyconsultants.com for more information.