It’s a rare business leader who relishes a crisis, but sometimes tough times provide the necessary impetus for firms to innovate. This particular economic downturn has certainly brought with it plenty o tough times, but at least one architecture firm has responded to the challenge by forging a groundbreaking alliance for the industry.
The recession has forced many architecture firms to downsize, while others have folded. According to the U.S. Department of Labor, employment in U.S. architecture firms plummeted by more than 25 percent between July and November 2009.
Chicago-based architecture firm Brininstool + Lynch was among the companies that felt the sharp sting of the recession. The firm saw its annual revenue fall from $4 million to $1.5 million and its staff downsized from 21 employees to eight.
After more than 20 years in business, the firm’s partners, Brad Lynch and David Brininstool, had certainly experienced their ups and downs. But rather than simply trying to ride out this particular storm, Lynch and Brininstool did something truly innovative. They joined forces with Tom Kerwin, a former managing partner in the Chicago office of Skidmore, Owings & Merrill, and Magellan Development Group, one of Chicago’s largest real estate developers, to launch a brand-new firm: Brininstool, Kerwin and Lynch LLC.
Under this unique alliance, Magellan will invest at least $1 million in the architecture firm, which includes a significant minority stake in the company. Kerwin is the firm’s managing principal, while Brininstool and Lynch serve as principals. Brininstool, Kerwin and Lynch also has six other staff members.
After more than two decades at one of America’s leading design firms, Kerwin was drawn to the possibilities of the new business, and he served as matchmaker in bringing together Brininstool + Lynch and Magellan, two companies that had never worked together before. “The chance to start a new enterprise with the backing of Magellan and the strength and design talent of Brininstool + Lynch was a dream come true, an opportunity I couldn’t let pass by,” Kerwin said.
Magellan is far from a newcomer to the architecture industry. Magellan co-chairman Jim Loewenberg is an architect himself and the president of Chicago-based architecture firm Loewenberg Associates.
“High-quality design must remain a critical factor in our business plan,” Loewenberg said. “We’ve worked with some great architects in Chicago, but our relationship with Brininstool, Kerwin and Lynch promises to be even more rewarding.”
Another point of synergy in the alliance is that both Magellan and the architects focus on the same market: multifamily residential. “High-density residential projects in urban settings is at Magellan’s core, and they’ve been quite successful,”Kerwin said. “Both firms have also been focused primarily in Chicago and the Midwest and have similar goals in reaching out beyond Chicago, particularly internationally.”
That’s where Kerwin’s strengths come to play in the new entity. At Skidmore, Owings & Merrill, Kerwin spent much of his 23 years doing international work. Neither Magellan nor Brininstool +Lynch had any international experience, so the firm will rely heavily on Kerwin’s international experience and contacts.
In the near term, Brininstool, Kerwin and Lynch will look to Asian markets for international expansion,but firm leaders are also planning trips to Brazil and other countries. Kerwin said that while the luxury housing market is having problems in the U.S., he’s bullish on international prospects. “The need for housing and other related uses is still strong throughout the world,” he said. “People are still moving back into cities, particularly in those countries moving from agricultural to service-based economies.”
“Tom’s international experience will enable us to deliver the same kind of service to a much larger audience,” Brininstool said. The firm is already working with a Dutch developer to design a large Chicago housing project and pursuing projects internationally with a Korean developer that has an alliance with Magellan.
The new entity came together in breakneck speed. Kerwin left Skidmore, Owings & Merrill onthe last day of 2009, and the new firm launched on January 25.
Since the new firm is such a rare entity, there were unique challenges that needed to be overcome in structuring the new LLC and in forging the operating agreement. “This was a unique deal with an outside investor taking a share in the firm,” Kerwinsaid. “It had every aspect of deal-making with three different parties who didn’t work together in the past now coming together into a new entity.”
The parties needed to decide how the firm would be funded, how money would be spent and how money would be returned. A great deal of time was also spent on compensation issues, deciding how to transition projects and project leads from the old architecture firm to the new one, and governance issues in terms of how the firm was allowed to operate.
Even though Magellan is a minority shareholder in Brininstool, Kerwin and Lynch, the architecture firm operates independently and is free to pursue other clients. “We are separate and branded separately, and we’ll work with other developers, clients and institutions. The idea is Magellan will be our client in certain cases,” Kerwin said. “On the flip side, Magellan can choose to hire us or look to other architects as well. It’s not an exclusive arrangement by any means, but there are incentives for us to work together where the opportunity works right.
“It’s a pretty unique enterprise; I don’t know of another example. There are certainly examples of new firms starting with seed money and examples of firms merging, but the combination of multiple layers is different, so there were really no models to work from. But I think we did our diligence, and I got informal help from key leaders involved in the architecture business.”
Brininstool, Kerwin and Lynch plan to move into a permanent new office space in the same building as Magellan by July 1. The new firm also has access to Magellan staff.
Ed Hannan is vice president of publishing at PSMJ Resources Inc. in Newton, Mass. Details can be found at www.psmj.com.


